We keep hearing about the importance of IQ and EQ for a leader, and people often question which of these is most important.
I always come down on the side of EQ, it’s EQ which allows us to get the best out of our teams. It’s EQ which allows a leader to leverage our networks, build trust through empathy with our teams and have that self knowledge which allows us to be authentic.
But actually I think one of the most important aspects for a leader is DQ.
DQ is Delivery Quotient, the ability of a leader to deliver results, to get stuff done.
Leadership is ultimately about achieving things, it’s impossible to be considered a good leader if you never achieve anything, no matter how charismatic, authentic or likeable you are.
However, you can’t be a great leader if just have DQ alone, although I have worked with many leaders who did. If you only have DQ, then you definitely have the ability to get things done, achieve results, but more often than not you lose the team because of a lack of empathy.
I worked with one leader who did a fantastic job of delivering a large transformational project, but at the end of it, no one wanted to work with him again. People looked to get from under his control, some even choosing to leave the company to ensure they didn’t have to work with him.
When I discussed this with him, his people skills that is, he said ‘people skills don’t matter, only results matter!’ .
Now whilst it’s true that results are important, the fact that he had left a trail of dead bodies, people who loathed him, who never wanted to work with him again, meant that it would be practically impossible for him to sustain success.
To be considered a great leader, or even just a good leader, we need to have a track record of sustainable success and for this DQ alone is not enough.
Great leaders have a blend of IQ, EQ and DQ, they are live in the sweet spot which is the intersection of these.
If you have the right mix EQ and DQ, then we can build powerful teams which are inspired, well motivated and have great teamwork, and if you add authenticity, a good vision to the leadership, you will have an organisation that can achieve anything.
As potential leaders, or existing leaders, we should assess ourselves in these three areas and see where we are strong and where we weak and look to strengthen those areas in which we have improvement potential.
Just focusing on improving our EQ will not make us a great leaders if we lack delivery capability, and if we just focus on our DQ and have little to no EQ, then we will never fulfil our potential.
Great leaders are well rounded, they are authentic, and have strong emotional intelligence and excellent delivery capabilities.
So which area do you need to focus on, in order to become a great leader?
Hello Gordon,
Job Talent (JT) encompasses DQ, EQ and IQ which may explain why hiring for job talent is so successful at identifying future successful employees.
JT = (DQ)(EQ)(IQ); as any item approaches zero, Job Talent approaches zero
Job Success = (Competence) x (Cultural Fit) x (Job Talent)
JS = (C)(CF)(JT)
JS = (C)(CF)(DQ)(EQ)(IQ) as any item approaches zero, Job Success approaches zero
The above does not mean we should hire applicants…
– who are the most competent (C)
– who have the best fit with the culture (CF)
– with the best Delivery Quotient (DQ)
– with the greatest Emotional Quotient (EQ)
– with the highest Intelligence Quotient (IQ)
When hiring we need to maximize job success (JS) which means we need to maximize the combination of all five terms.
Bob, i fully agree with you. I think as well that in different circumstances your scores for DQ, CF etc could be different to what they are in others.
We should always be looking to hire of JS, and as employees we should be looking to show our JS and not just or EQ or DQ
Hello Gordon,
80% of employees self-report that they are not engaged.
80% of managers are ill suited to effectively manage people.
The two 80 percents are closely related.
Employers keep hiring the wrong people to be their managers and then they wonder why they have so few successful, engaged employees.
Successful employees have all three of the following success predictors while unsuccessful employee lack one or two and usually it is Job Talent that they lack.
1. Competence (C)
2. Cultural Fit (CF)
3. Job Talent (JT = [DQ)(EQ)(IQ])
Employers do a…
A. GREAT job of hiring competent employees, about 95%
B. good job of hiring competent employees who fit the culture, about 70%
C. POOR job of hiring competent employees who fit the culture and who have adequate or better job talent, about 20%
Identifying the talent required for each job seems to be missing from talent and management discussions. If we ignore any of the three criteria, our workforce will be less successful with higher turnover than if we do not ignore any of the three criteria.
1. Competence
2. Cultural Fit
3. Job Talent
There are many factors to consider when hiring and managing talent but first we need to define talent unless “hiring talent” means “hiring employees.” Everyone wants to hire for and manage talent but if we can’t answer the five questions below with specificity, we can’t hire or manage talent effectively.
1. How do we define talent?
2. How do we measure talent?
3. How do we know a candidate’s talent?
4. How do we know what talent is required for each job?
5. How do we match a candidate’s talent to the talent demanded by the job?
Most managers cannot answer the five questions with specificity but the answers provide the framework for hiring successful employees and creating an engaged workforce.
Talent is not found in resumes or interviews or background checks or college transcripts.
Talent must be hired since it cannot be acquired or imparted after the hire.
Bob,
I would have to agree it is a balance. I have had discussions with other mangers where I have stated that some people…no matter how good technically do not belong on your team. This often equates to somebody with a high IQ but limited EQ. They tend to isolate their team members and often should not be in front of customers. Occasionally it is worth keeping these people in the short run. I have also seen managers that wear everybody out. In the short run they get results but in the long run leave a broken group or company as you discussed. They typically move on so somehow magically survive on what was perceived as a major success. One CEO I had used to stress that sometimes you have a person that is not getting results but is compliant with the organization culture and mission. He used to stress in this case you may have a good person in the wrong role. So switching them into a more compatible role should create success. If they still do not get success then you have someone that does not belong. The person that gets results but does not seem to help the culture he said was a difficult person to decide on. You need to determine if this person is pushing the organization to where we need to be…or is just a loose cannon that is better off not being in the organization in the long run.
Jim Collins says ask yourself 2 questions
1/ if the person left would you be disappointed
2/ if the person was available, and knowing what you know now, would you rehire them
if you answer no to both those questions then you have a resource issues
I love the simplicity of these 2 questions
because it allows you to ask was the success we achieved worth it, would i want to go through that again – and often with some manager,s even though we were successful id rathe do it with someone else as there had to be a better way
Gordon, excellent topic! The simplicity of Collins’ 2 questions is profound. The answer to either question could be circumstantial and requires reflecting and looking deeply before answering. It also means taking stock in where the organization is headed. In every case it takes honesty, conviction and courage.
mmicom
I love the 2 questions because if you answer the honestly, and its not easy to do that, then you have a clear understanding of where you are with each individual.
It’s tough but worth it.
Hi Gordon,
There is no reason to hire the “1/”.
Managers should know the answer to “2/” prior to the job offer.
Asking the questions is easy, knowing the answers before the job offer is made is also easy but we need to know what questions to ask and how to evaluate the answers.
“id rathe do it with someone else as there had to be a better way”
There is a better way, It is called hiring for talent.
This article is great as far as it goes…I agree, but we need to step up…it omits the most important Q, PQ, the leader’s Positive Quotient(R)–my trademark (sorry you cannot use it)….this is the key to implementing all the other Qs.
Without this Q, IQ will ignore or trample feelings, EQ will focus on the the upsets and negative emotions trying to manage them and DQ ( love this, whoever thought of it should trademark it) will end up alienating people as in your story!
Dr. Linne Bourget MA MBA Ph.D., Pioneer, Positive appreciative strengths-based leadership,
http://www.whatyousayiswhatyouget.com
Author, What You Say Is What You Get(R) Positive Leadership Series, Positive Quotient(R), and Appreciative Quotient(R) Questionnaires.
Dr Linne, thanks for the comment, i came up wit the term DQ and will look at trade marking it
I think the IQ and DQ needs to be at the minimum level required for the specific job to potential by an OKAY leader. The EQ is what differentiates the okay/good leaders from great leaders. I also find that IQ can be the lowest of the three- a strong EQ carries the greatest impact overall when it comes to leadership and performance overall.